Cleveland, GA – TMU Criminal Justice professor Jeff Branyon, an expert with 35 years of experience in American law enforcement and forensics, presented at a forum in the Archbishop’s Hall in Rijeka, Croatia, on how criminal investigation methods can be applied to the question of Jesus’ death and the empty tomb.
In the hall of the Rijeka Archbishop’s Palace in Rijeka, a historic port city on the Adriatic coast of Croatia, the “Fokus” Association and the “Alfa” Team organized a forum on Wednesday, March 11, where Branyon invited attendees to investigate what he called the “greatest crime in human history” – the murder of Jesus Christ. In a unique lecture, Branyon used criminalistic and forensic methods to examine the mystery of Easter.
Branyon brings 35 years of experience in U.S. policing and seeks to apply detective methods to historical questions surrounding Jesus’ death and resurrection. The lecture drew a large crowd, particularly young people, filling the hall to capacity. It was delivered in English with simultaneous translation by Domagoj Malović from the Fokus Association. Organizers thanked the Archdiocese of Rijeka for the use of the venue, noting that Branyon had never lectured in a more beautiful setting.
From Criminalistic Methods to the Gospels
The lecture was divided into two parts. In the first, Branyon outlined procedures used in criminal investigations with examples from his career. In the second, he applied those methods to the events surrounding Jesus’ death.
“When we investigate any case, we must be aware of our own prejudices. Every one of us has a certain bias,” Branyon said, emphasizing the importance of examining all available evidence. He cited differing worldviews as an example: some believe only in natural laws, while others accept the possibility of the supernatural. “If we reject the possibility of miracles in advance, we might automatically discard part of the evidence,” he noted.
Branyon added that although many believe science and faith cannot coexist, forensic analysis can help examine historical events described in the Bible. He cited testimonies in the New Testament as foundational sources, noting that the Gospel writers present themselves as eyewitnesses.
Theories on the Empty Tomb
Discussing Jesus’ death, Branyon reminded the audience that most historians agree Jesus was crucified and buried. He then reviewed alternative theories explaining the resurrection. One suggests Jesus did not die on the cross but entered a coma-like state and later revived. According to Branyon, medical and historical evidence does not support that claim.
He also addressed the Gospel of John’s description of a Roman soldier piercing Jesus’ side, with blood and water flowing out. “Today we know this description corresponds to a medical condition called pericardial and pleural effusion, the accumulation of fluid around the heart and in the chest cavity,” he said, noting the author likely recorded what he observed without medical knowledge.
Extra-Biblical Testimonies
Branyon also referenced non-biblical sources mentioning Jesus, including the Roman historian Tacitus and the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus. While their accounts vary in detail, both reference the execution of a Jewish teacher crucified by the Romans.
He also examined the theory that the disciples stole Jesus’ body from the tomb to fabricate a resurrection. In his view, such a conspiracy would have been difficult to maintain, especially since the disciples continued preaching publicly and many were later executed.
“Forensic Faith”
At the conclusion of the lecture, Branyon explained the conclusion he reached through his analysis of historical and textual sources.
“In a courtroom, a verdict is reached based on evidence ‘beyond a reasonable doubt.’ This does not mean there is no doubt, but that the conclusion is the most reasonable based on the available facts,” he explained.
He described three types of faith: “blind faith” (without evidence), “unreasonable faith” (despite evidence), and “forensic faith,” which is based on evidence.
“As a police officer, I spent my career investigating crimes and searching for evidence. That same search for truth led me to faith,” Branyon concluded.
Truett McConnell University is a private Christian liberal arts and sciences university located in
Cleveland, Georgia, and has been ranked by Best Value Schools as the #1 Christian College in Georgia. TMU offers 80+ different programs of study including baccalaureate, master’s, and doctoral degrees. The University boasts a 15:1 student-to-faculty ratio while 100% of incoming students receive financial aid. For more information about Truett McConnell University, visit www.truett.edu
Return to News Archive